Cuba

¿Hasta la Victoria Siempre?*

Before coming to Cuba, I had a very limited understanding of the country’s political structure; I simply knew that it was a communist society that rejected United States capitalism. Little did I know that this fundamental piece of knowledge affects every aspect of life in Cuba. Enduring faith in the Revolution of 1959, coupled with a vehement clinging to “socialism,” makes for a country with as strong nationalistic tendencies as that of the US and an utter denial of any problems that the people encounter daily.

As mentioned in a previous post, there is no advertising in Cuba. Instead, no matter where you go, you’ll see propaganda praising the Revolution, Fidel, or Martí, or denouncing the US embargo. The most common phrases are “Hasta la Victoria Siempre,” “Viva la Revolución,” “Yo Soy Fidel,” and “Bloqueo: El genocidio más largo de la historia.” The last one is especially strong. Not only do these phrases pervade every street corner, they pervade the news. Nearly daily, the front story of the main newspapers, La Granma (named after the boat that revolutionaries Che Guevara and Fidel and Raúl Castro used in their attempts to overthrow the Batista regimen) and La Juventud Rebelde, talks of something related to the legacy of the Revolution, Fidel, or Martí. The same goes for news on television. However, as quick as Cubans are to criticize the US in conversation, they do not do so directly in their news sources. Any articles reporting happenings in the US are very objective, except when they report other countries harshly criticizing the US. The Cuban papers themselves do not take a stance.

Due to the prevalence of so much propaganda, it’s not surprising that Cubans are unwilling to discuss any challenges or failures that have arisen since the Revolution. In some respects, having a socialist society has been incredibly beneficial for Cubans. Education is free and guaranteed up to age fourteen; health care is advanced, specialized, and free as well; rent and bulk foods are highly subsidized. Then again, there are cracks in all of these systems.

In terms of education, everything is regulated by the government. Yes, it’s fantastic that Cubans, regardless of province or wealth, all receive the exact same education, learn the exact same curriculum, and take the exact same tests. But there is no open discussion. There’s no room for debate, nor room to discuss topics, opinions, or perspectives that stray from that of the government. Moreover, after the guaranteed years of schooling, students go on to pre-University and University, which they must repay through 3 years of social service. And getting into University is no breeze – the highest marks are required, and even then there is a waiting period.

In terms of the health care system, there are also drawbacks. Health care is split into primary, secondary, and tertiary levels. There are family doctors that live in neighborhoods as primary care providers, followed by polyclinics. If you can’t find a doctor with the right specialization in the clinic, you’re referred to a secondary provider that can get to the heart of your problem. All of the divisions are overseen by the tertiary level, the Ministry of Public Health. This all sounds very nice and organized, especially when you consider how many specialists are found in the country – doctors not only work in every health field imaginable, but they also are found in drug rehabilitation and psychiatric centers, domestic violence support centers, maternal health care centers, etc. The issue: as much as the system proclaims itself to be equal for all, it all depends on your neighborhood. Some neighborhoods don’t have a known family doctor; some have clinics with very few resources. Without these two aspects of primary health care, receiving secondary health care becomes very difficult. On top of this, doctors are paid very little by the government; you can earn much, much more as a taxi driver, tricking tourists into paying exorbitant fees. One doctor we met was willing to concede that there are problems. It was refreshing to hear a Cuban actually admit to a desafío in the country, even if it was “The system isn’t perfect, but it can be perfected.” The main takeaway is, though very diverse and attentive, the health care system is not as accessible as it professes to be.

Basic needs such as housing and food are provided under the socialist regime, but there are even problems there. The government rations food based on each family’s size and needs, but the rations are not sufficient. In addition, people here never “comprar,” or buy food, they must “buscar,” or look for food. Our host mother blames the field workers and restaurants for the struggle. The farmers, she says, do an insufficient job, and the restaurants buy up all of the good food, such as cheese. The latter might be true, but the workers are simply not cultivating enough food because of the government. With a fixed salary, they have no incentive to work longer and harder to cultivate more food. As for housing, it’s virtually guaranteed – there are really no homeless people here – but it comes at a cost. There aren’t enough houses. Three generations of Cubans often have to share single floors of homes, and buying a house is nearly impossible. It’s no wonder that so many Cubans leave the country once they’ve finished their education; as a young Cuban, you can’t gain much independence if you’re still living with your parents and grandparents. This emigration then exacerbates another problem. 20-30% of the Cuban population is age 60 or older and population growth has nearly stopped in the last four years.

Despite all of these problems, Cubans will very rarely admit to any issues. If you try to pry them with questions, whether carefully phrased or not, they’ll either change the subject, blame someone else or some other country, or continue with all the positive aspects of the topic. There is only one political party here, and contradicting it in any way is dangerous. (Ironically, the government claims itself to be a democracy – yes, you’re free to vote for anyone, but the candidates all represent the exact same values.) The party knows who goes out and votes; furthermore, there is suspicion of secret police still crawling around the streets, listening in on conversations.

Initially, I was uncertain about my view of socialism, since all I was hearing was its successful implementation in Cuba. Yet after a month, I’ve seen and heard its flaws, and am no longer so sure. That’s not to say that I’m so proud of how the US is run and that I think its political system is wholly better. In fact, that’s where my frustration lies. We Americans are so willing to criticize our government and debate issues, and Cubans are willing to as well – but not when it comes to their own country. Thus, it’s basically useless trying to have a discussion on politics with Cubans, when both sides can openly denounce the US, but never Cuba. I hope that in my last few weeks here, I can come closer to some meaningful discourse, but after so much struggle, I won’t expect it.

*If I’ve gotten some facts wrong here about different aspects of Cuba’s government, I apologize; I’m only going off of information I’ve taken from conversation, not various books or internet sources. I may have misunderstood or mixed up some components.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Climbing in Cuba

February 22, 2017

Stylin'

March 4, 2017

Verified by MonsterInsights